Help talk:Talk pages

From finiki, the Canadian financial wiki

Archivelist styling suggestion or guideline

There does not seem to be any guidance on Wikipedia's Help:Archiving a talk page on how to layout or style the archive list. The Example 2 seems to most closely match our potential use case of archives covering a year or a number of years. Just using a numbered list does not seem to be an appropriate use of space in {{Archives}}.

Searching for better practices, in Talk:Main Page/archivelist we have tried, which was copied from the Wikipedia page User talk:Izno/archivelist:

Markup Renders as:
<div style="column-count: 2">
# [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 1|2009]]
# [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 2|2013]]
# [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 3|2020]]
</div>

There is a small but noticeable vertical alignment problem when multiple columns.

A better solution might be:

Markup Renders as:
{{flatlist|style=text-align: center;|
* [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 1|2009]]
* [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 2|2013]]
* [[Talk:Main Page/Archive 3|2020]]
}}

Since we generally use years or year ranges it makes the most sense to me to use a bullet list rather than a numbered list in this case.

Using the <nowki>style=text-align: center;</nowiki> keeps the list center aligned with the rest of the {{Archives}} output.

--Peculiar Investor 19:03, 8 February 2023 (UTC)