Dividend reinvestment plan
A dividend reinvestment plan or DRIP is a mechanism where dividends or distributions paid out by a security are automatically used to purchase new units or fractional units of the same security (e.g., [1][2][3][4]).
The main types of DRIPs are as follows:[1][5]
- Synthetic DRIPs, offered by discount brokers, for securities such as stocks and Exchange-traded funds (ETFs)
- ETF DRIPs, offered directly by ETF providers
- Mutual fund DRIPs, offered by mutual fund companies or by brokers
- So-called 'true' DRIPs, managed through a transfer agent and dealing with individual companies or closed-end funds
The first two types of DRIPs allow purchase of whole shares only (e.g., [6]), causing a minor (or even negligible[7]) "cash drag" on returns, whereas the last two types of DRIPs offer partial shares or units.[5]
Synthetic DRIPs
Synthetic DRIPs are offered by discount brokers.[1] They exist for both registered and non-registered accounts.[1] They allow investors receiving dividends or other distributions from stocks or ETFs to automatically reinvest these dividends into the same securities, almost always at no additional cost.[8] Only whole shares can be purchased that way;[1] whatever is left of the dividend will accumulate as cash. Setting up a synthetic DRIP typically involves calling the broker and asking for dividends to be reinvested, although some brokers allow you to do this online. Some brokers will DRIP everything (Scotia iTrade, QTrade, Questrade)[8], whereas others publish lists of eligible securities, for example:
If the security you are interested in also has a 'true' DRIP, and that this particular program offers a discount (see below), then some brokers will honor this discount through their synthetic DRIP.[9]
Note that in non-registered accounts, you will have to record every dividend/distribution reinvestment to track your adjusted cost base, and that several ETFs have monthly distributions, meaning 12 transactions to record per year (for each security). This is not an issue in registered accounts.
The remainder of this page relates to DRIPs managed through a transfer agent and dealing with individual companies or closed-end funds.
Individual company or closed ended fund DRIPs ('true' DRIPs)
Some companies allow investors to automatically reinvest their cash dividends by purchasing shares including fractional shares on the dividend payable date, without paying brokerage commissions.[1][2]
Dividend reinvestment plans are operated directly by the company (or their agent) and therefore there can be differences is how each company's DRIP operates. For example, some companies offer a discount incentive, typically 2 to 5%, in their dividend reinvestment plan.[1] Companies may also offer their DRIP members the ability to make additional cash purchases, also known as a Systematic investment plan (or alternatively Share Purchase Plan).[1][2]
The rest of this page deals with the process of setting up true DRIPs.
Advantages and disadvantages of 'true' DRIPs
Advantages
Advantages of a 'true' DRIP versus purchasing shares via a brokerage include:[1][2]
- no brokerage commissions to purchase more stock via Optional Cash Purchase (OCP) plan;
- automatic dividend reinvestment;
- fractional share ownership;
- discounted share purchase price (typically 1-5%).
Disadvantages
Disadvantages of a 'true' DRIP versus purchasing shares via a brokerage include[citation needed]:
- relatively small number of companies offering DRIPs directly (lack of diversity);
- not all companies offering DRIPs offer OCPs (additional shares would have to be purchased via a broker, negating one of the benefits of a true DRIP);
- OCPs not processed daily; most are monthly or quarterly (may result in purchases at an unfavorable time);
- complexity of obtaining an initial share;
- for a taxable account, an order of magnitude increase in the number of transactions to be tracked for the adjusted cost base (ACB), plus extra attention to be paid if a partial sale triggers a superficial loss.
The sections below address one disadvantage of true DRIPS - complexity of obtaining an initial share. The process of obtaining the initial share via direct transfer, using the two largest transfer agents, is explained in detail and has been used to successfully transfer shares between investors.
To remain an active DRIP investor requires owning a non-zero number of shares in a company. This number could be "less than 1" if fractional shares have been credited to the holder's account as part of a dividend reinvestment. (discussion on DRIP investing board)
In order to participate in a company dividend reinvestment plan (DRIP), one must obtain a share in a company offering a DRIP. This can be done by buying a share through a brokerage or by finding another DRIP shareholder who is willing to transfer a share.
The total cost of obtaining the share from a brokerage be quite high. Assuming an investor has access to a brokerage account, below certain account size thresholds, trading commissions cost as much as $29.
A $20 share plus the $29 trading commission, plus the $50 certificate fee would result in a total cost to obtain the share of $99, for a $20 share, a premium of $79.
Many DRIP investors choose to participate in share exchanges - transferring extra shares between each other - to avoid the costs involved in the brokerage approach of obtaining shares.
Buying a share from another investor with an existing DRIP, a $10 gratuity is typically added to the share price. A $20 share would therefore cost the new owner (transferee) $30, a premium of $10.
The sections below detail the process of direct share transfers.
The transfer agent requires the following to process a share transfer:
- a completed & signature guaranteed share transfer form (linked below)
- a completed letter of instruction (blank templates linked below)
- a share certificate OR instructions to transfer from the Dividend Reinvestment plan balance
In order to fill out the above forms, the following information is required:
- the name and address of the person you are transferring to (the "transferee")
- the certificate number of the share you are transferring OR the account number of the Dividend Reinvestment plan if transferring from that balance
- your personal information exactly as it appears on file/on certificate (name & mailing address)
- a piece of personal ID with your signature in order to have all documents signature guaranteed
The process for assembling the above documents differs slightly between Computershare and Canadian Stock Transfer Co. The specifics of each are posted below with direct links to the pages required to complete the process.
Specifics of each transfer agent
Computershare's interactive help page is here: Shareholder Services (Enable browser cookies to view)
Computershare has an interactive agent called "Penny" to guide transferees through the share transfer process.
Declaration of ownership form
From the "Ask Penny" interactive assistant: There are companies for which a Declaration of Ownership is required. To determine if your company requires a Declaration, please refer to our Downloadable Forms section.
While the interactive assistant does not specify who should fill out this form, email responses from Computershare customer service indicate some companies require this form to be filled out and sent in with the transfer paperwork. This would require the new owner to fill out the paperwork and send it to the original owner for inclusion in the transfer documents.
Other correspondence with Computershare indicates that for small numbers of shares, the form is not required. While that threshold has been specified, discussion on the DRIP information discussion forum suggest it to be quite high, in the range of 10% of the outstanding shares of the company.
One company, National Bank, requires that the form be signature guaranteed (see the section on signature guarantees below) and sent with the transfer documents, regardless of the number of shares.
The direct share transfer form is here: Securities Transfer Form, with instructions on page 2.
The Computershare website should always be referred to for the most up to date, valid securities transfer form. However, a fillable PDF version has been developed and is available for direct download, here: Computer Securities Transfer form, fillable PDF
Mailing addresses
Their mailing address is listed in the same section:
Computershare Investor Services 100 University Ave. 8th Floor, North Tower Toronto, Ontario M5J 2Y1
Canadian Stock Transfer Company
Canadian Stock Transfer Company (CST) has a page to guide you through transfers, here: Basic Transfers
Clicking on the "Securities transfer form for shares and warrants" link opens a form page that generates a pre-filled PDF file for print with a guide for entering correct information.
CST's mailing addresses are linked on the sidebar of the above page:
By Mail
Canadian Stock Transfer Company
P.O. Box 700, Station B
Montreal QC H3B 3K3
By Courier
Canadian Stock Transfer Company
2001 University Street, Suite 1600
Montreal QC H3A 2A6
-OR-
Canadian Stock Transfer Company
320 Bay St., B1 Level
Toronto ON M5H 4A6
Olympia Trust Company
More information on the the securities transfer process with the Olympia Trust Company can be found on their website, here: http://www.olympiatrust.com/transfer-agent/transferring-securities
A direct link to their securities transfer form is here: http://www.olympiatrust.com/transfer-agent/pdf/Security-Transfers.pdf
In an email response from Olympia Trust Company on 6 July 2012, they indicated that securities transfers should be accompanied by a Letter of Instruction.
Further, as share certificate issuance via Olympia has a fee associated with it, transfers could be made requesting only a dividend reinvestment plan balance transfer, with no new certificate issued. This should be specified in the Letter of Instruction.
Letters of instruction
Blank "Letter of Instruction" templates as suggested by Computershare's interactive helper, Penny, are posted here:
- Canadian Stock Transfer Co Letter of Instruction Template (MS Word file)
- Computershare Canada Letter of Instruction Template (MS Word file)
Signature guarantees
Regarding the Signature Guarantee:
- Visit a Canadian Schedule I charter bank indicating a requirement to have securities transfer forms signature guaranteed.
- CAUTION: Signature Guarantees from CIBC may not be accepted by transfer agents[10]; avoid the risk and use another institution. (TD Canada Trust is known to be acceptable)
- Ensure the bank witnesses signatures on all documents, dating, stamping, numbering, and signing in the area reserved for the signature guarantee. (a sample is provided on the back of the Computershare transfer form; print it on the back of the form for reference by the bank employee)
- This process has been done by those who are not a bank customer but being a client of the signing bank may avoid objections by less-than-knowledgeable staff.
On completing and signature guaranteeing the required documents, mail them to the appropriate transfer agent at the addresses listed above. Processing can take several weeks during which time transferee and transferor should stay in contact and confirm the receipt by the transferee of the new share certificate.
Post transfer
Receiving shares is significantly less laborious and time consuming than sending them.
If an owner has used the above-documented transfer process, the transfer agent will mail the new certificate directly to the new owner. With the certificate information (issuing company, certificate/account number, registered name and address) the new owner can register for an account on the transfer agent's web site where their security will be listed.
Canadian Stock Transfer Company's "AnswerLine" online account registration page is here: https://www.canstockta.com/WbisRegWeb/AnswerLineRegDisplay.do
Computershare's "Investor Center" online account registration page for Canadian residents is here: https://www-us.computershare.com/investor/registration.asp?cc=CA&lang=en&context=DataEnvironment=LIVE%7CServerRegion=Americas%7CRegSystemEnvironment=LIVE%7CServerMode=LIVE%7CServerUse=INTERNET
It is important to sign up with same information the securities are registered under (exact spelling of name and address, exact certificate/account number) to ensure the account is correctly linked with securities held.
Existing accounts with transfer agents
If a transferee already has an account with a transfer agent, share information will most likely be added to the transferee's portfolio information online prior to the physical share certificate arriving in the mail.
Transfer processing times
Typically, Canadian Stock Transfer Company processes transactions more slowly than Computershare. On receipt of paperwork, the former can take several weeks to process a simple share transfer where Computershare may only take a week once the paperwork is received. Canada Post or courier transit times must be taken into account as well.
Canadian Stock Transfer Company, after receiving properly filled and endorsed securities transfer paperwork, has been known to:
- debit a share from the original owner's account
- create a new share certificate, placing it in the original owner's certificated share balance
- remove or cancel the certificated share and mail the new share to the transferee
The above seems convoluted but has been verified by several members of the DRIP Investing Resource Centre forum[11] and the end result is a successful transfer to the new owner.
See also
References
- ^ a b c d e f g h i John Heinzl, There’s more than one way to set up a dividend reinvestment plan, The Globe and Mail, Updated March 24, 2017, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ a b c d www.dripprimer.ca, About DRIPs, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ Imperial Oil, Dividend reinvestment and share purchase plan, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ BMO InvertorLine, Frequently Asked Questions -- Dividend Reinvestment Plan, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ a b John Heinzl, Good to the last DRIP: Five ways to reinvest, updated March 26, 2017, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ Vanguard Canada, Distribution reinvestment plan, viewed March 18, 2018.
- ^ Justin Bender, The DRIP myth, December 4, 2014, viewed February 23, 2019.
- ^ a b The Globe and Mail, Broker DRIPs, updated June 19, 2017, viewed February 25, 2019.
- ^ dripprimer.ca, Canadian Discount Brokers, viewed February 25, 2019
- ^ post by awesomeness on DIRC Canadian DRiPs Message Boards, CIBC Signature Guarantees
- ^ post by CJOttawa on DIRC Share Exchange Message Boards, Positive Feedback for Renee
External links
Canadian DRIPs
- Justin Bender, The DRIP Myth
- Canadian DRIP Primer with SPP calendar, sector breakdowns and more
- Canadian Stock Transfer Company Inc.: Dividend Reinvestment Plans Overview
- The Stingy Investors' Drip List
- The DRiP Investing Resource Center
- Do you DRIP?, Financial Wisdom Forum discussion.
- Synthetic DRIP, Financial Wisdom Forum discussion.